Quick comparison between:Whites TDI SL
Minelab XT 18000
Use search box below to compare Whites TDI SL with something else
|Options||Whites TDI SL||Minelab XT 18000|
|Battery Type||8 AA|
|Operating frequency||6.4, 20, 60 kHz.|
|Ability to change coils||Yes|
|Number of Reviews|| 2
|Avg. User Rating||3.00||5.00|
|Avg. Durability Rating||4.50|
|Avg. Ease of Use Rating||4.00|
|Avg. Depth Rating||No data available yet|
Most helpful review for Whites TDI SLTDI SL, where's the beef?
I have used all three models of the White's TDI and still have a couple of units. The SL works, but disappointingly nowhere near the depth of the other two models. Have have both the 7 and 12 dual field coils. The 7 inch was just plain sad on this detector, many of my VLF detectors are more responsive.
Do not get me wrong, I use and have many White's fine machines, but this one needs much more to be a winner in my book.
Mick from San Francisco
Read all reviews for Whites TDI SL
Most helpful review for Minelab XT 18000The xt18000's
These are simply the best Minelab gold VLF's that were made. But there are two different models of the XT18000, the early and the late, and they are vastly different units.
The 'early' 18000's have a very loud audio and a terrific sensitivity to them in both the 60khz and 20 khz frequency's. You can actually "feel" the 60khz penetrating into and feeling it's way amongst the dirt, but not very far, only an inch or so, which in this frequency ( as in all very high frequency detectors ) is about all the depth they will get you on very small pieces of gold. The 60khz will hit on larger pieces a bit deeper though, but not much deeper. The 20khz an allrounder.
The 6.4khz on these models however is a very dull frequency and only suited for the big coils and thumbnail size targets and up. The early models would blank out and shut down over very large surface targets and severe ironstone outcrops etc.
The later model XT18000's, which have a white stripe on the tone dial and had the box bracket mounted under the forearm, had a very low audio. Pathetically low. What they did have though, was a fantastic "audio supression" in them. This meant that they would not blast your ears over large targets. But the best thing with this new audio suppression was that when worked with a good signal enhancer, the threshold could be brought way up into your ears to judge slight dropout's and rises in the threshold ( meaning very deep targets could be heard quite distinctly ) but large surface targets dulled down to protect your hearing.
The 20khz and 60khz on these later models were some how not as sensitive as on the early models....But....The 6.4khz was much more sensitive on them than the earlier model. A real killer on smallish and deep targets.
On my late model unit I can run the big 14.5" WOT coil along the side of a car and drop off the other end and the detector recovers itself instantly. Amazing detector.
The automatic ground balancing on these units leaves the auto tracking on detectors like the Lobo supatrack and MXT's and GMT's for dead in hot ground. That is the truth...Whether the Whites or Tesoro dealers like it or not.
I have made many good gold finds with my 18000's and cannot recommend them highly enough to other detectorist's for gold detecting.
I hope this helps someone.
Dual Ace from Victoria, Australia
Read all reviews for Minelab XT 18000