Quick comparison between:

Fisher F-19
and
Whites DFX


Use search box below to compare Fisher F-19 with something else

Fisher F-19
Whites DFX
Feature comparison between Fisher F-19 and Whites DFX
Options Fisher F-19 Whites DFX
Detector Type Coin and Relic Detector Coin and Relic Detector
Price $800 $1000
Manufactured in 2014 2001
Battery Type 9V 8 AA
Weight (Lbs.) 2.5 lb 4
Operating frequency 19 kHz 3, 15 kHz.
Display Yes Yes
Backlight Yes Yes
Target ID Visual ID 191 Segment Numeric+Icons
Tone ID Adjustable iron audio, tone discrimination 1 or 191 Tones
Search Modes
  • Coins
  • Coin/Jewelry
  • Jewelry/Beach
  • Relic
  • EEprom DP Silver
  • EEprom Hi-Trash
  • EEprom Hi-Pro
  • EEprom Demo
Ability to change coils Yes Yes
Ground balance Auto, Custom
Waterproof Coil only Coil only
Warranty 5 Years 2 Years
Number of Reviews graph 5
graph 1
graph 71
graph 15
graph 2
graph 5
graph 3
Avg. User Rating 4.83 4.52
Avg. Durability Rating 4.67 4.24
Avg. Ease of Use Rating 4.83 3.71
Avg. Depth Rating
Depth value
Depth value

Most helpful review for Fisher F-19

Sleeper unit??
Have had my F19 now for a few months, and wow!! I really like this machine. I have had a number of detectors over the past few years, and find this is a keeper. Hits rock solid on good targets (for me, that means round targets, rings, coins and the such)... I am mostly a park jewelry hunter and find this machine gets the job done, very well! Runs nice and quiet, steady and solid... The Target ID, is amazing with this machine, at least mine is... I'm pretty impressed. Like others say, may not be the deepest, but not a slouch either... I'm always amazed at the depth I get with the stock coil. The V-Break makes it even more downright fun! I don't see a whole lot about the F19, not sure why... During research I heard there may have been some issues that some folks were having with the early model, but that you could send in to Fisher and they would rectify... But that the next batches had the fix...

All I know is that I could not be happier with the F19... Love the backlight as well... The ease of use, how balanced it is, the V-Break, the Tones, Disc, etc etc... For my needs... Pretty darn good and it earned itself a place in the stable of units I will not be selling. Just a lot of fun - heck even targets at depth the ID remained pretty solid! Being a jewelry hunter, I don't rely on target ID... But it is fun to have it and dig up things and see how or whether the machine was right or not... More often than not, this one is on the money. Is it perfect? Are any of them? Lol - Suits my needs to a T. One of my favorites, period. Have not tried it on the beach though so can't speak for that aspect.
Happy hunting!
Ron from Phoenix

Thumbs up! 57
Read all reviews for Fisher F-19

Most helpful review for Whites DFX

Not a tough to learn as usually claimed.
I've owned the DFX for 2 years. I have several hundred hours logged with this detector and overall I'm fairly pleased with its performance. As stated in the title, the machine isn't that difficult to use. The settings are fairly self explanatory, though the toughest part of actually learning the DFX is finding clever ways to make the settings work together. Some settings impact others (ex sweep speed vs recovery speed vs filters used). This is a mixed blessing with this machine. One the one hand, you have the ability to truly customize, on the other hand it's easy to screw it up and come home empty handed. Also it takes a bit of tweaking at each site which can be time consuming as conditions change in the field. Experimentation is the best way to learn and gain experience. I've found that while there are very good books which can help you explore the DFX, it's really the conditions you personally face which will allow you to find your own best setting.

Depth: It's difficult to truly judge how deep a detector will detect, many things have to be taken into accout, but overall this machine will find 95% of the coins that are there to be found. My one dislike is that the DFX tends to break up fairly badly on deep targets, the Signagraph will also jump around. If the audio is somewhat repeatable with some bars to the right, dig the target. You might be surprised.

Pinpointing: The DFX is an outstanding pinpointer with a concentric coil provided you have ratchet pinpointing OFF. The VCO also helps to determine the depth accurately. Note that the VCO on and DC SENS up will make the detector squeal even though the target may be over 4 inches deep.

Signagraph: Helpful, but can be misleading in some instances. It wants to display iron along with a good target in highly mineralized soil. Overall, a good tool. Listen to it, use the graph as an assistant.

Discrimination: Very good, although setting discrimination with the menu can be a chore. Block edit is still confusing to get right. Small gripe but a grip nonetheless.

Dual frequency: I've found the DFX does a better job when 1 frequency is used in some conditions. Tailor the mode to the targets you intend to find. IE 3KHz coins and 15KHz in the jewelery department.

Battery life: For what this detector does, it's quite excellent.

Build and Customer Support: Second to none for both. My DFX has been used and abused. It's held up extremely well considering it's a computer on a stick. When severely abused, White's has always replaced or repaired no questions asked. Simply outstanding customer support.

My Likes:
GB offset - Makes significant difference on small deep targets. A setting not discussed, but a very powerful option.

Discrimination - Compared to other detectors I rank this one near the top.

Bells and whistles - if you get to know them, they can be a real advantage.

Accesories

Build quality and balance.

Adjustable filter settings - you'll know what I'm talking about when you hit a trashy patch, notching the machine to 2 filters makes it quite snappy.

Backlight - Very useful

Key shortcuts - Quick adjustments

DC Phase - Good way to gauge mineralization

Pinpointing

DISLIKES:

Susceptible to interference

Slightly Heavy

Need more EEPROM slots for custom programs

Out of the box, performance is abysmal.

Inter-related settings can really increase need for ibuprofen. If in doubt, reload the program.

Very choppy on deeper targets compared to some other machines I've used.

That's about it. I hope you were able to get something out of the review. It's by no means a perfect machine, but it can come very close with a bit of practice and knowing how to tweak the controls properly. This thing is suitably deep for most hunts, this statement is also subjective.
Artur from Duluth, MN

Thumbs up! 153
Read all reviews for Whites DFX