Quick comparison between:

Whites TreasureMaster
and
Fisher F44


Use search box below to compare Whites TreasureMaster with something else

Whites TreasureMaster
Fisher F44
Feature comparison between Whites TreasureMaster and Fisher F44
Options Whites TreasureMaster Fisher F44
Detector Type Coin and Relic Detector Coin and Relic Detector
Price $299 $400
Manufactured in 2015 2015
Battery Type 2 AA 2 AA
Weight (Lbs.) 2.8 2.3
Operating frequency 7.812kHz. 7.8kHz.
Display Yes Yes
Backlight No Yes
Target ID 8-Segment 9-Segment viisual and numerical
Tone ID 4 Tones Adjustable Iron Audio
Search Modes
  • Coin & Jewelry.
  • Beach.
  • Relics.
  • All Metal.
  • Pinpoint.
  • Jewelry
  • Coins
  • Artifact
  • Custom
  • All Metal
Ability to change coils Yes Yes
Ground balance Auto Computerized Ground Balancing + Manual GB
Waterproof Coil only Weatherproof, waterproofcoil
Warranty 3 Years 5 Years
Number of Reviews graph 3
graph 1
graph 4
graph 2
graph 2
Avg. User Rating 4.00 3.50
Avg. Durability Rating 4.25 3.88
Avg. Ease of Use Rating 4.75 4.75
Avg. Depth Rating
Depth value
Depth value

Most helpful review for Whites TreasureMaster

Pro features, amateur price.
It's been a very long time since we've seen anything TRULY new from the big "W". The MX5 was the last 'new' machine but was based on MXT technology. While it did pretty well, it never really seemed to find it's market. It's priced up there with the AT Pros but never garnered the respect the AT Pro gets.

Enter the Treasuremaster. I've been detecting 30 years, and I've used 'em all. This little machine has more 'pro' features than any other machine out there in it's price range. It's sensitive, deep, easy to use, lightweight and should give that little banana colored beeper some serious competition as the Treasuremaster isn't even in the same class as the Garrett Ace, but it's priced where the Ace is.

Real automatic ground balance, VCO pinpointing, adjustable target volume, 4 tone ID, 8 segment disc, threshold hunt (a sensitivity feature that no other detector has under $300), runs on 2 AA batteries for 20 hours and it's weatherproof. (Let's call it rainproof). It's weighs in at about 3 lbs. A little extra 'beef' than the featherlight detectors like the Tek Delta 4000 but the extra heft makes it feel like a better built detector.

I've had it out about 5 times now and have re-hunted some sites that I've been over. Finding a lot of clad. I'm not finding much in the way of serious keepers, but that's the fault of my location and not the detector. The detector hits coins very solidly and will lock on a target. Target ID is pretty much the same as other White's machines. 70's-80's are dimes/pennies/quarters, nickels ring up at a consistent 20-24, zincs read 59-61. I hunt in Georgia red clay and it seems to handle the hot soil well. You can hear the detector update the ground balance if you lift the coil about waist high and walk with it in the air. You'll hear a deep beep every few seconds.

Using it is as easy as turning it on, use the UP/DOWN arrow by the Options button to set a slight threshold and start swinging. If the detector falses, simply turn the sensitivity down using the +/- buttons. The various settings are selected by pressing the Option button and cycling thru the various tweakable settings.

The display numbers are large and easy to read. Not as big as the Fisher F series, but much easier to read than even my expensive MXT. I found the 4 tone ID a little annoying especially in hotter ground and it can false and cause some random low tones. Setting the tone ID to 2 tones solved that. Overall, the Treasuremaster is MUCH more machine than the Coinmaster/Pro series it replaces and MUCH more machine than it's target competition the Garrett Ace series. I think given some time, the Treasuremaster should become a popular choice in the vast array of detectors out there.
Jay Emm from Georgia

Thumbs up! 48
Read all reviews for Whites TreasureMaster

Most helpful review for Fisher F44

Fisher f44-great detector for the money
The F44 provides a lot of performance for a machine a little over $300. No other machine on the market has near the features of the F44 for the money. The custom mode, where tones can be assigned to each category, is an industry first that I'm sure many others will copy. Depth is very good for a low priced machine, and separation is decent.

Fisher advertises it as weatherproof, but I've found that if you're water hunting and happen to drop it, it won't leak. I wouldn't intentionally submerge it though. The build quality is good and light. Just because it doesn't weigh five pounds and made of steel doesn't mean it's not durable. Fisher machines are a lot tougher than they look.

This would be a very good beginner machine, as it's not too complicated. But I've got over 40 years in the hobby and don't feel at a disadvantage using it.
John Samsky from Manassas, Va.

Thumbs up! 33
Read all reviews for Fisher F44