Whites Beach Hunter IDPrice: $800
Based on 27 reviews
Avg. Durability: 4.00
Avg. Ease of use: 2.50
Looks great, disappointing
The coil floats so much as to be unusable in water. The TID lights seem great when standing next to it admiring it on a table, then when you try to hunt they immediately become difficult to use. They are along the side and you don't have good enough line-of-sight to make out what they are saying in any daylight. This is important because in order to have decent depth you need to run it in all metal mode. (The TID lights work in all metal.) Even then the depth is bad.
Ground balance knob has almost no effect that I could discern. If they fixed the target response and moved TID and the all metal switch to a module on a vertical handle like the ATX it would be fine.
Ease of Use
Would you recommend this to a new user? No, not really.
Fairway from America
Bh id a competent beach machine
You might want to adjust the sensitivity down a little until you get the hang of distinguishing noise from signals... Choppy signals are almost always ferrous trash, but if you are like me, it's hard to pass them over.
As to the floating coil and the coil flipping up... Just reverse the coil in the water, and you might want to shorten the tube... Then neither of these problems will be problems.
The BH id is a very competent, "universal" detector, that has discrimination, and also works in wet sand, and under saltwater quite well. I like to use it in conjunction with a light-weight but rugged scoop that is also a universal-use scoop.
This way one outfit can cover any part of the beach whenever you feel like moving from one part to the other. Such a scoop has to be lightweight for the dry and wet sand, but extremely rugged for under the water. I like the Howie Scoop as the ideal match for the BH id. Be careful transporting.
The headphone swivels that connect the headband to the cups break easily. No problem putting in new swivels from whites (cheap to free), but I could not pull out the old, broken nub from the ear cup socket, and it fell into the ear cup. It rattles around a little inside there. Not a big deal, but obviously, not what you want.
Don't overtighten the screws on the case if you open it up. Better to not wear the unit on your belt in the white's nylon carry case. The battery compartment latch came undone when I did that. I'm making a neoprene case for mine which will secure it much better. Do I recommend it for a new user? Yes...But with caveats, and some of these caveats apply to every water detector.
You must realize that it makes some noise in saltwater.
You must realize that you will learn quite quickly to distinguish most of the noise from signals. You can reduce the noise by reducing sensitivity and/or threshold...But you may reduce good signals too.
Use it in conjunction with a lightweight but rugged scoop, if you prefer wading to snorkeling. Realize it takes more effort to recover items in the water. You will get better at handling the detector and your scoop over time. Some folks use diving weights to help them hold position and dig (scoop). Also, know that you will find gold if you persist.
Ease of Use
Would you recommend this to a new user? Yes, absolutely!
Scaupus from South Florida
Want to point out..................
This always makes me laugh when I read this. If you're going to hunt beaches and water you want to also detect lead sinkers and pull-tabs.
If you're digging sinkers, that's where the older heavy gold will be. Nickels and pull-tabs, you have to dig many to find something good! What do you think, there's a magic machine you just wave and you're going to suck up all the lost jewelry on a beach (LOL)! Beach and water hunting is HARD work, Go ahead, turn up the disc and tune them out and leave the GOOD STUFF for me.. .. .. . Jeezzzzzz
Jay from Ny, Nj
Great idea! bad execution!
The electronics inside are coated with some type of spray to prevent water damage to the board (which works well. . but not in all cases). Not realizing the case had water in it, I turned it on. . . . it started making strange noises (so don't freak out if this happens the electronics are more than likely fine, if the case breaks 35 dollars for top and bottom to replace). Just let it dry out and find the leak,repair it or send it in. Once the electronic dry it will be OK. Make sure to replace the black seal to the orange seal (4. 95 whites store online).
Other than the issue with the coil floating and seal/heat fracture (I experienced) it is a great detector. I found about 8-9 gold rings and countless silver and relics with it. You will dig pull tabs! That is just part of the deal.
Trenchfoot from Wisconsin
I also use an x terra 705, while great in the wet sand, it does the normal jumping around in the salt water, just have to go slow, the surfmaster, your discrimination is listen to your targets and listen well!! It will save on digging up trash! I know tendonitis in your elbow can wreck your day.
Ralph Genovese from New jersey
Okay, But Has Couple Issues
Whites switch to a orange gasket that does not leak, if you buy a used BH ID, be sure it has the orange gasket, not the black gasket.
The coil flots, it is an irritation, can't be call a flaw, but it just makes no sense why a detector built for underwater would have a coil that floats.
The LEDs are suppose to tell you good or bad target, but LEDs will report pull tabs, pieces of aluminum foil and bottle caps as good targets so you will still dig all. I also found small pieces of iron, that LED did not always report as iron.
I have followed other hunters on the wet sand and found targets behind them, but that can be said of all detectors as some hunters swing in a 180 degree arc and speed walk the beach..
Over all in the wet sand, dry sand, and regular ground it is a good detector, but I can not recommend it in the water, there are better detectors for that.
I own 2 Excals 1000s with WOT coils and 2 Sovereign GTs and feel they are much better detectors for the beach...
Treasure Hunter from Florida
BEACH HUNTER ID
First and most important run sensitivity as high as you can and still be able to recognize a steady signal yes its a little bit noisy but you'll get way more finds second tip trust the machine if its chattering multiple lights red, yellow green so on most likely bottle top, toy ect but I have had yellow green mix that was ring, all in all great machine family user friendly. but I stress keep sensitivity high as you can with out it jumping of wall try a bench test with sens. on p setting run ring by it see how far you can get away from loop, then boost sens. to little less then 7/8 max thats were I like it, you will notice difference of inches. third tip if you get multiple color and tone alert signals going crazy stop you must make sure its not multiple items take your time try to separate each signal if you can because you have a big loop many items can be under there at one time try to pick them apart separate them, its worth the time. I hit an area it went nuts green red yellow red but how you tell the difference is if you take time seperate them with center loop you will get a steady signal green green green then your in the money. This machine is well worth the money, well good luck lucky.
LUCKY from FLORIDA
IF YOUR A DIG ALL HUNTER
Chad from Florida
Great out of the water,unhappy in the water
I bought this unit in the spring and used it extetively out of water and very happy with the results. Maybe more time in the water will change my outlook. The coil in the water is also a concern. I've partly solved this problem by adding a PVC tube closed at both ends filled with sand attached to the lower shaft close to the coil with plastic twist ties (no metal) contact. Also bought a bracket to keep the coil from moving up or down. Other wise I think its a great detector,just hoping to master it in the water.
Joel-Winnipeg from Winnipeg Man. Canada
Good on land but frustrating to use in water.
Steve from Mayport, FL